[PUG] Elton John vs Billy Joel

[invisible]

who do you prefer - elton john or billy joel?

please vote on poll.

 

[This]

Billy Joel: Although I think Elton is probably the better musician Billy Joel's lyrics really speak to me.

 

[poshlost]

both are just okay.
edit: well, elton > joel

 

[invisible]

both are not just ok

 

[poshlost]

oops, I did it again.

 

[poshlost]

I actually think Elton's music is pretty awesome, but it's coated in layers upon layers of cheese.

 

[arbygil]

Billy is a better lyricist, Elton's a better pianoman. But I prefer better lyrics, every time.

 

[bamf]

Billy is a better lyricist, Elton's a better pianoman. But I prefer better lyrics, every time.

I agree with you on the lyric part, but I highly doubt that Billy wrote this for Elton.
[ame="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gxEPV4kolz0"]YouTube - Billy Joel - Piano Man[/ame]

Billy>Elton in both lyrics and skill!

 

[AUM]

How about instead of "Billy Vs Elton" we say "Billy and Elton". It sounds much better.