D'ya think so?
I don't really know anything about you, so I can't assume what you do and don't know about the series...However...
If you're from the U.K and you were into Who or just read the papers around about the time Tennant was Doctor, you'd have seen that he got pretty much EVERY girl. There was a time when you'd get an article every week/month about Tennants new girl, and she was always without fail one of the recent actresses appearing on Who.XD For example, he dated the lady who portrayed Madame de Pompadour and even his own 'daughter' Jenny!
Pretty studly if you ask me!
Also, the tenth Doctor is the ONLY Doctor to have kissed EVERY ONE of his companions (female or male) at least once, if not repeatedly. Not to mention Rose/Martha were after him the whole time, and various other girls. (C'mon, he snogged Minogue. That puts him like a million points ahead of Smith!)
As far as I recall, apart from the odd boast that we can't quite confirm, the 11th Doctor just has River and Amy, and Amy's married...so really just River. (And we're still not sure which Doctor she originally became infatuated with, it might not even be the 11th though t'was heavily hinted so.)
Hahah, what a stupid thing to form a logical argument over. XD