Peppermint
Well-known member
- MBTI
- uwot
- Enneagram
- _
What is wrong with the bill?
Potential for abuse. Some would say it will certainly be abused.
What is wrong with the bill?
Potential for abuse. Some would say it will certainly be abused.
Join the Blackout
Dear MoveOn member,
Tomorrow, MoveOn.org will go dark. No news, no information, no resources. Why? Because we're protesting Internet censorship.
Websites all over the Internet, including sites like YouTube and even MoveOn.org, could be made unavailable if big entertainment companies, the Chamber of Commerce, and their lobbyists get their way by ramming Internet censorship legislation through the Senate.
That's why tomorrow, Wednesday, January 18, we're joining Reddit, Wikipedia, Mozilla, Wordpress, TwitPic, Boing Boing, and thousands of other sites and blacking out MoveOn.org in protest.1
What is wrong with the bill?
They're likely unfounded fears. The only people who have to worry about SOPA are the Pirates as they risk being prosecuted by content creators if SOPA is enacted and seeing as how I don't pirate anymore, I really couldn't care less about them.
They're likely unfounded fears. The only people who have to worry about SOPA are the Pirates as they risk being prosecuted by content creators if SOPA is enacted and seeing as how I don't pirate anymore, I really couldn't care less about them.
Why this doesn't actually stop piracy
This legislation is aimed at requiring private U.S. entities to enforce restrictions against foreign sites but does nothing against the infringement itself. All of the enforcement actions can and will be worked around by sites focused on copyright infringement. U.S. citizens will still be able to use foreign DNS servers, new advertising and payment networks will pop up overseas, and "infringing sites" will still be linked to by other foreign sites and search engines. In fact, tools used to circumvent these forms of internet restrictions are being funded by the U.S. State department to offer citizens under "repressive regimes" uncensored access to the internet. When the dust settles, piracy will still exist, and the internet in the U.S. will have entered the realm of federal regulation and censorship.
They're likely unfounded fears. The only people who have to worry about SOPA are the Pirates as they risk being prosecuted by content creators if SOPA is enacted and seeing as how I don't pirate anymore, I really couldn't care less about them.
Steam, a bastion against piracy works by providing a better service than pirates which people then are willing to pay for.
[TABLE="class: cf gJ"]
[TR="class: acZ"]
[TD="class: gF gK, align: left"][TABLE="class: cf ix, width: 404"]
[TR]
[TD]Fight For The Future
[/TD]
[/TR]
[/TABLE]
[/TD]
[/TR]
[/TABLE]
Today was nuts, right?
Google launched a petition. Wikipedia voted to shut itself off. Senators' websites went down just from the sheer surge of voters trying to write them. NYC and SF geeks had protests that packed city blocks.
You made history today: nothing like this has ever happened before. Tech companies and users teamed up. Tens of millions of people who make the internet what it is joined together to defend their freedoms. The free network defended itself. Whatever you call it, the bottom line is clear: from today forward, it will be much harder to mess up the internet.
The really crazy part? We might even win.
Approaching Monday's crucial Senate vote there are now 35 Senators publicly opposing PIPA. Last week there were 5.
And it just takes just 41 solid "no" votes to permanently stall PIPA (and SOPA) in the Senate. What seemed like miles away a few weeks ago is now within reach.
But don't trust predictions. The forces behind SOPA & PIPA (mostly movie companies) can make small changes to these bills until they know they have the votes to pass. Members of Congress know SOPA & PIPA are unpopular, but they don't understand why--so they're easily duped by superficial changes. The Senate returns next week, and the next few days are critical. Here are two things to think about:
1. Plan on calling your Senator every day next week. Pick up the phone each morning and call your Senators' offices, until they vote "no" on cloture. If your site participated today, consider running a "Call the Senate" link all next week.
2. Tomorrow, drop in at your Senators' district offices. We don't have a cool map widget to show you the offices nearest you (we're too exhausted! any takers?). So do it the old fashioned way: use Google, or the phonebook to find the address, and just walk in, say you oppose PIPA, and urge the Senator to vote "no" on cloture. These drop-in visits make our spectacular online protests more tangible and credible.
That's it for now. Be proud and stay on it!
--Holmes, Tiffiniy, and the whole Fight for the Future team.
___
P.S. Huge credit goes to participants in the 11/16 American Censorship Day protest: Mozilla, 4chan, BoingBoing, Tumblr, TGWTG, and thousands of others. That's what got this ball rolling! Reddit, both the community and the team behind it, you're amazing. And of course, thanks to the Wikimedians whose patient and inexorable pursuit of the right answer brought them to take world-changing action. Thanks to David S, David K, Cory D, and E Stark for bold action at critical times.
P.P.S. If you haven't already, show this video to as many people as you can. It works!http://fightforthefuture.org/pipa/
I received that same reply from my Congressman. Here's whats wrong with the bill.
I have a video up on Youtube. There are two things a casual viewer might notice about it.
1 - There's a 25 second clip in the beginning that is an audio recording of speech by Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Its use falls well within the "Fair Use" laws since it's under 30 seconds and I claim no commercial gains, but a person without full knowledge of those laws might cry "copyright infringement!"
2 - I use a song in that video that I legally obtained the copyright for. I have it saved as an electronic document in my email directly from the artist's representative. There is no way for me to display this document alongside the video, all I can do is put in the credits that the song is used legally. Unfortunately, since the proof is on my end, someone can come along and claim I don't have permission to use the song.
With SOPA and PIPA, not only would my video be in danger of being shut down without notice given to me, but Youtube as a whole would also be subject to those same repercussions. On top of that, my ISP would then be held responsible for my use of their bandwidth in uploading that video.
Meanwhile, I was well within my legal rights to post that video and I had all the documentation needed, but I never had a chance to so much as argue my case. I was essentially guilty until proven innocent. As a result, everyone now risks being "policed" by these individual sites, their ISP and the search engines that link to them all.
It's like the Salem witch hunts where all someone had to do is look at someone sideways and risk being accused of witchcraft. Only now, we've changed the labels to "Piracy" and "Pirates".
Search engines are going to have to monitor their results to disable any results that link to "questionable" sites. Domain hosts are going to have to monitor and disable any sites that get complaints. Web sites themselves are going to have to restrict who can post what, where, for what reasons, or else get accused of "piracy". ISP's are going to monitor YOUR activity to make sure YOU personally, don't do anything questionable - if they suspect you are, consider yourself offline.
Even a forum like this isn't safe. Think about how many people post here. All one person has to do is link a picture, video or file that another person finds "questionable" and INFJ Forums will be nothing but an error screen from that point on.
Are you starting to get the picture now?
Why the fuck would pirates be worried about SOPA? They're already illegal. The one thing SOPA an PIPA will fail to even dent is piracy.
I see this as a case of seriously misplaced priorities. Do the three of you know the same hooting and hollering was made when the Patriot Act was enacted? That law has real ramifications to your civil liberties and freedom and not just taking away your right to post copyrighted music on Youtube. In any event, SOPA and PIPA aren't going to pass seeing as how President Obama already unequivocally stated that he would veto the bill if it came across his desk. So at best this fuss is a big hoopla about nothing.
I see this as a case of seriously misplaced priorities. Do the three of you know the same hooting and hollering was made when the Patriot Act was enacted? That law has real ramifications to your civil liberties and freedom and not just taking away your right to post copyrighted music on Youtube. In any event, SOPA and PIPA aren't going to pass seeing as how President Obama already unequivocally stated that he would veto the bill if it came across his desk. So at best this fuss is a big hoopla about nothing.
I oppose SOPA, but I'm peeved at how websites are "blacking out." They purport to be engaged in an Gandhian "action through non-action" protest, but the best way to get me to appreciate the internet would be to let me access it as normal. Gandhi's statement is often misinterpreted. He didn't sit silently, and he definitely didn't do nothing at all. He was extremely vocal and active. The non-action he spoke of seems primarily to refer to violence - which isn't even in question when we are talking about this technological infrastructure.
All it takes is a small banner in the corner to remind me of how much you hate the government.
Also, if SOPA is passed - which I seriously doubt will happen, given how much people love pirated music and porn - it would likely be hard to enforce. Collectively, the masses of internet users have more knowledge about technology than the government, and they would figure out a way to keep their internet running.
As a personal aside, I wouldn't really care if it was passed and fully enforced. All I use the internet for is communication with other people, and I think that would be allowed to continue, albeit with certain changes.
They could even take it one step further, and start scanning my emails for terrorism threats and illegal activity. I don't care. I have nothing to hide.
SOPA was first posted on the House of Representatives' website in October. Why has it taken this long for discussion to start?
If you wish to discuss the bills, please cite their actual texts, which can be found here:
HR 3612 "Stop Online Piracy Act" (SOPA) from the House of Representatives' website.
http://judiciary.house.gov/hearings/pdf/112 HR 3261.pdf
S.968 "Protect IP Act of 2011" (PIPA) from the Library of Congress.
http://www.gpo.gov/fdsys/pkg/BILLS-112s968is/pdf/BILLS-112s968is.pdf
It severely diminishes your credibility to reference blog posts, blackout pages, and YouTube videos when official, legal documents exist.