I am going to agree 100% that men and women cannot be plutonic friends within a certain degree (There are always exceptions to the rule). That degree is mainly attraction. If I am really attracted to a girl, I cannot be her “friend”. It doesn’t mean I am going to be a jerk but I am not going to sit around and listen to her talk about the guys she likes. It’s awkward because the whole time I am thinking, “I could treat you better” which means I am not being a true friend so I am not going to do it.
I am a guy and therefore I don’t want to be treated like one of your girlfriends. If I am really attracted to a girl, I don’t want to hear her talk about other guys. Just as I am sure that girls who really like a guy don’t want to hear him talk about the girls he is interested in. You can talk about sports, video games, family, work, school, etc… pretty much anything but relationships and crushes. Call me egotistical but I don’t like being treated like I am a girlfriend.
However if there is no attraction then I agree it is possible. I am one of two guys in my office. The rest are all female and I have no interest in them and so we are friends. The reason behind this is:
One, they are all at least a few years older than me,
Two, I don’t dip my pen in company ink, it causes too much drama and too many problems,
Three, they are beautiful women but none of them appeal to me in that way, and
Four, it shouldn’t need to be said but it happens too often, they are all married and I don’t pursue other guys love interests. I think it’s the lowest of the low and it’s a line I won’t cross.
And to answer the other question, yes I have been called a flirt but I am not an INFJ. Flirting is fun, sorry. It’s not always about sex, sometimes it’s just fun have that type of banter with a girl.