- MBTI
- infj
- Enneagram
- ....
88chaz88;62030 especially when I don't even share their faith.[/QUOTE said:Well thats sort of the crux of what I am talking about.
1. what faith? Faith in what? Not the tenets of the religion clearly.
88chaz88;62030 especially when I don't even share their faith.[/QUOTE said:Well thats sort of the crux of what I am talking about.
1. what faith? Faith in what? Not the tenets of the religion clearly.
How do you know what it takes to be a 'real christian?' Is there a particular verse you're referring to, or just dogma?
@acd I'm not a christian, nor do I go to church. I just try to understand the bible from a christians perspective.
You've not convinced me. I'm gonna need specifics, otherwise you're just bullshitting.Yes. The whollllllllle 2nd part of the bible where Jesus showed up, the one that invented the religion and holds the rules of the religion you are blatantly ignoring.
lol youre implying I was being deceitful. did I take the bait?Got it. thanks for finally being honest.
Do you understand what a parable is? It is a story to teach a lesson. Just because you understand how communism works doesnt make you a communist. You must understand the lesson Christianity teaches, not believe the literal occurances at face value.Incorrect. You have to literally believe that Christ rose from the dead, in order to be a real Christian. Moreso that he died for your sins, to say that that's just a parable, is absurd. Its like saying I am a communist but don't believe in any of its tenets or follow any of it, and yet still proclaim the title for myself. Its nonsense.
I guess a better way of saying it would be "the Bible operates as a parable." If it's soothing that you think it literally occured, by all means believe it; but remember it has a lesson to teach as well! Some people get hung up on the literal happenings and miss out on the meaning. I'd just like for that not to happen.Do you also think vegetarians who label themselves as such but still eat fish and/or chicken are really vegetarians? They believe they are, so that must mean it's true.
Also, was gonna mention before that Kmal never claimed to be a Christian. Since he actually came right out and said it now, let me just say, not surprised! I had a hunch that was so, because I honestly can't imagine a truly devout Christian saying something like "Jesus being risen from the dead was a parable". It makes a lot of sense for a non-Christian to relate to that story in such a way, but not so much for an actual Christian.
I guess a better way of saying it would be "the Bible operates as a parable." If it's soothing that you think it literally occured, by all means believe it; but remember it has a lesson to teach as well!
This has nothing to do with what I believe, I am not a Christian. I am simply saying that, that is not how actual Christians view it. I get your point, truly. I even agree. But again, I am not a Christian. If I were, I would disagree. There are many stories in the bible that would be referred to as parables by Christians, but the resurrection of Christ is not one of them. That is an actual literal belief of the faith.
I'm kind of bored, so I'll chat about this a little bit.I do not now believe that brother J rose from the dead. However, I was raised Christian, and back when I was Christian I did believe it quite literally..
Christianity is a religion of orthodoxy, meaning right beliefs or right ideas. Not all religions are (Judaism is i.e. a religion of orthopraxy, right actions). That means to call yourself a christian you have to profess as true a certain list of beliefs, such as the Nicene Creed. One of the items on the list is believing that Jesus rose from the dead...
The most irritating example of this was one of my brother's old girlfriends, who pastored a Church of Christ, and who did NOT believe in the virgin birth, did NOT believe in the resurrection, did NOT beleived that Jesus died for the sins of the world, did NOT believe that Jesus was the messiah... She was basically an ethical monotheist, but hardly what I'd call a Christian.
alize there are well meaning "cultural" Christians who have been raised with Christmas trees and Easter Egg hunts and pictures of Jesus surrounded by children. They have lots of sentimental ties to Christianity, but they just don't make the cut when it comes to that profession of faith. I can understand their emotional NEED to identify as a Christian, but, well, no cigar. Knowing the 23 Psalm by heart doesn't make you a Christian.
On the other hand, these cultural Christians obviously aren't Muslim, Atheist, Toaist, or Wiccan. Do you see what I'm saying? While not strictly Christian, there is no other box they fit into. So be nice to them. They WANT to belong.Taize does a version of the Kyrie where they pray "For those who CANNOT believe, Kyrie eleison." I remember thinking how kind that prayer was, that it showed compassion rather than judgment. After all, if a person doesn't believe, its not because they are "bad," but simply because they are not convinced. .
I'm kind of bored, so I'll chat about this a little bit.
I do not now believe that brother J rose from the dead. However, I was raised Christian, and back when I was Christian I did believe it quite literally.
Christianity is a religion of orthodoxy, meaning right beliefs or right ideas. Not all religions are (Judaism is i.e. a religion of orthopraxy, right actions). That means to call yourself a christian you have to profess as true a certain list of beliefs, such as the Nicene Creed. One of the items on the list is believing that Jesus rose from the dead.
The most irritating example of this was one of my brother's old girlfriends, who pastored a Church of Christ, and who did NOT believe in the virgin birth, did NOT believe in the resurrection, did NOT beleived that Jesus died for the sins of the world, did NOT believe that Jesus was the messiah... She was basically an ethical monotheist, but hardly what I'd call a Christian.
I realize there are well meaning "cultural" Christians who have been raised with Christmas trees and Easter Egg hunts and pictures of Jesus surrounded by children. They have lots of sentimental ties to Christianity, but they just don't make the cut when it comes to that profession of faith. I can understand their emotional NEED to identify as a Christian, but, well, no cigar. Knowing the 23 Psalm by heart doesn't make you a Christian.
On the other hand, these cultural Christians obviously aren't Muslim, Atheist, Toaist, or Wiccan. Do you see what I'm saying? While not strictly Christian, there is no other box they fit into. So be nice to them. They WANT to belong.
Taize does a version of the Kyrie where they pray "For those who CANNOT believe, Kyrie eleison." I remember thinking how kind that prayer was, that it showed compassion rather than judgment. After all, if a person doesn't believe, its not because they are "bad," but simply because they are not convinced.
Seems like my post was so long ago
What are your thoughts on the 'real christian?'I just want to go on record as saying I do literally believe that Jesus rose from the dead. Watching nonchristians argue amongst themselves as to who is a Real Christian[SUP]tm [/SUP]Is kind of funny to me though.
What are your thoughts on the 'real christian?'
Oh Hi there, I'm Joe Blow, Im a christian, I mean in name... like I dont believe anything in the bible, I dont believe any of it was real, I dont believe that Christ died for my sins or that he even existed, or that he rose from the dead, I just dont believe any of the actual doctrines of faith required to be a Christian in practice, but i'm a christian.
I guess that makes sense.