- MBTI
- ENFP
- Enneagram
- 947 sx/sp
I am sorry but this is one of those subjects that unless you've dealt with it, you really shouldn't talk about it.
There’s no need to apologize for speaking your mind, and in any case, I absolutely agree with you. And so I talked about it because I’ve dealt with it. I’ve been overweight, and I have been obese. I’ve was told that I was ruining my looks, that I would look so much better if I was thin, that people would like me more, that I would make more money, that I would be more of a man if I wasn’t fat.
But you know what? I wanted to be fat...because when you are fat, you become a kind of invisible...and for sure, people avoid you, they don’t want anything to do with you. And that’s exactly what I wanted. Because after having been raped for the second time, I could protect myself by making myself and my body undesirable, unwanted, disgusting even. Don’t look at me, don’t talk to me, and definitely don’t fucking touch me. And it worked!
People often reduce this issue to health....
And I certainly did in my post because that was purposefully the context I was addressing. It doesn’t mean that I was/am not aware of the long list of other considerations.
...but that's only one part of the story. The medical community has made it a thing to target people who are not the standard weight and make them feel self-conscious and bad about it, even when it is not the main issue or cause of a visit. I have been treated rudely like I was nothing because I was overweight. Doubly, if you are a woman of color. They are often insensitive, patronizing, or overly simplistic in their diagnoses because they want to blame having weight on for everything, even if it is not the issue. There are so many cases of women finally sharing their stories of medical issues being overlooked or concerns being dismissed because the doctor rushed to judge the issue as weight-related.
Yes, understood and agreed. Part of me being a medical nerd is not just the hard science, but the psychological and sociological aspects of the doctor-patient relationship. Some of my best-received posts on Reddit have been about patient advocacy, disparities of outcome when comparing and contrasting sex, gender, and race, with a special emphasis on rates of infant and maternal mortality in the United States for women of color, cross-referenced with other nations. And women are routinely ignored and not listened to, regardless of their weight, or so say the women I interviewed for the U of MN, but inasmuch as I’m not one, I wouldn’t really know anything about that, would I?
Another thing is, my weight is mine and mine alone to discuss. If I would like advice on it, I will ask. Otherwise, I shouldn't be subject to someone's opinion or judgment about it unless they are directly affected by it, they are directly involved with me, and care about me the person. I know I have a weight issue. I don't need someone to tell me that. The focus should be health, not my weight alone. I can be healthy and not be small. That's a fact.
Agreed, and that’s why I was clear about the context in my post. It was between doctor and patient, because a doctor is the only person that would be appropriate to make comment, and those comments were about health. I certainly wasn’t giving anyone advice.
I remember having family members as a child call attention to weight as the first thing they notice and commenting on it publicly in front of others to shame. Honestly, someone's weight is no one's business, unless you are affected by being in this person's life and are involved with them in some way.
As in, for example, their doctor addressing their health. Which is what I posted about.
I’m a bit confused by your reply, because I’m not sure if you agreed or disagreed with my post. You seemed to take issue with it, but you didn’t actually address the idea of it, so that left me wondering.
Thanks,
Ian