D
Deleted member 16771
This is very interesting. I'm INTJ and your parents are the same types as mine.Dad - INTJ
Mom - ESFJ
Brother - INTP
My mom and brother fought like cats and dogs. Now I understand why.
First time I took MBTI, I got INTJ. Sometimes I feel like an honorary NT. I was always closer to my dad and brother, and have had so many deep, philosophical, intellectual conversations with those two. I still occasionally wonder if I'm actually INTJ or INTP. I'm also Ennea 5w4, so maybe that combined with the fact that I have high Ti, and that my brother and dad are both NTs could explain why I second guess my INFJ-ness sometimes. Could inf-Fe manifest as aux-Fe when you're put in a position as a child to be the peacemaker while simultaneously being emotionally abused?
As regard to your question, though - I've often played a peacemaker role in my family, even though I'm an Fi-user, so that in itself doesn't reveal much. I think maybe if we looked at the reasons why you acted as the peacemaker, and the way you went about it, that might reveal something useful.
I'll tell you why/how I do it and put an Fi-spin on things to see if you resonate. To me, when family are fighting, my feeling is that 'this family is too small and precious to fight, and nobody's getting estranged on my watch', and then I'll argue something like 'this issue is too insignificant to fight about; get your priorities in order and make up'. Sure it's not nice that family are fighting, but the prevailing emotion is that principles of family loyalty and love are being violated, and I just want to tell them to grow up, remember their priorities, and fucking behave. I think this is an Fi way of reacting and doing things; it's more disappointment that the family is violating the 'ethics' of being a family. 'Fi-peacemaking' I think is more accusatory and judgemental. I'll say things like 'Yes, your grandmother is annoying sometimes, and she might have hurt your feelings, but that's no reason to never speak to her again. She's still your grandmother and this family is too small for anyone to become estranged. Think about what your priorities are and apologise.' If I were to characterise Fi-peacemaking in a phrase, it would be 'fuckin behave'
By contrast, Fe becomes more clearly upset by the disharmony in the family. The Fe-peacemaker will feel physically affected by the hostile vibes, rather than being annoyed and disappointed, and will absolutely need to fix things and for people to get along. I'm speculating, but I think the 'solutions' of the Fe-peacemaker will also tend to be much more conciliatory; the solution will be about compromises and mutual affirmation, rather than the Fi-peacemaker's focus on ethical priorities and moving past the issue. If I were to characterise 'Fe-peacemaking', it would be 'please stop fighting ' (this is how I reacted to my mum and dad arguing as a very small child).
The Fi-peacemaker will naturally expect the solutions to come from within each individual involved ('you need to forgive your mum'), whereas the Fe-peacemaker might default to seeing the solution in a mutual agreement or compromise ('we need to fix this'). Of course, everybody uses both, however, and so this is not a dead giveaway.
As to you possibly being INTP and inferior Fe being forced to develop... this is possible. The easy way of looking at that, though, is that when there isn't any conflict or otherwise 'necessity' to use a particular function, what do you default to? In which function do you live? For me, I absolutely live Ni; I'm constantly spacily wondering about a singular summative idea and exploring its elements. You would feel the same if you were INXJ.
If you were INTP you would live in Ti, constantly thinking about the foundational principles of things and how they are wrong/right, &c., which would be supported by the 'one million ideas per second' style that is Ne (which is also how you would present to people).
Last edited by a moderator: