muir
Banned
- MBTI
- INFJ
Have a second look on this. Are you sure that's what you wanted to write?
careful...you are getting perilously close to offending me and hurting my feelings
Have a second look on this. Are you sure that's what you wanted to write?
careful...you are getting perilously close to offending me and hurting my feelings
Not giving a straight answer again.
Let's try again: are you sure that you want to compare the current opposition to your opinions to the struggles of all Jewish people and zionists? Are you saying that Jews, the single most persecuted religious minority in the history of mankind, are whiny people and need to shut up about the countless exterminations they have faced?
Are you trivializing the struggles of all Jewish people based on the 2-10% that have achieved financial/scientific/artistic success?
if you take a 'jew' to be someone of an ethnic group (i personally do not...i see a jew as someone of the jewish faith) then it appears that those people who have taken over the levers of power are ashkenazis who cannot claim to have an ancestral right to the land of palestine because their ancestors did not come from palestine...they were from khazaria (as jewish geneticists and historians will tell you)
If you're born to a Jewish mother, you're a Jew. Every denomination and stance on judaism agrees to that. If you were born to a Jewish mother and are not a practitioner of Judaism, you're a Jewish atheist/christian/muslim/buddhist/whatever.
How about you do some research yourself. You can find a geneticist and a historian to say whatever you want them to say. There's thousands of them. The fact of the matter is that there's historical proof of the existence of Jews in the area surrounding and in modern Jordan, Lebanon and Israel. They're finding Jewish ancestors in Khazaria because they were expelled from their land after the Temple fell.
Why am I going on here, this is pointless.
EDIT: Technically a Jewish atheist/Jewish Catholic/whatever.
Muir I like how you translate from one language to another and then back again in order to prove words mean what you want .
[h=1]race, religion, politics and culture
Shlomo Sand: 'There are Israeli, not Jewish people'[/h]
[video=youtube;cq6EPYLfcM0]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cq6EPYLfcM0[/video]
Shit, Shlomo Sand said it?
That completely negates the Halakha (Deuteronomy 7:1-5, Leviticus 24:10, Ezra 10:2-3), the Mishnah (kiddushin 3:12), and the modern Judaic religious denominations!
Then you are defining being jewish as an ethnicity
You could read the work of prof schlomo sand who then looks at how there is no unified ethnicity of a jewish people
Also as a jewish geneticist has proven the ashkenazi jews behind the political movement known as 'zionism' are not descendents of the biblical jews they are decendents of the khazars from khazaria who converted enmasse to judaism over a 1000 years ago
This means that the zionist claim that the 'jews' have a historical right to the land of palestine is what the nazis would call a 'big lie': https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Big_lie
This is why those khazarian jews that we call ashkenazi jews speak yiddish not biblical hebrew
No you cannot be a jewish catholic
You are either of the jewish religion or the catholic religion...you cannot be of both
Their ethnicity would depend on their genetics
There are black jews from ethiopia for example and there are ashkenazi jews who came from khazaria NOT from palestine etc
First of all, thank you for comparing me to nazis. It filled my heart with joy.
Shlomo touches on an important debate, one that's hotly contested in Israel: who's Israeli and who's Jewish, and are they one and the same? That's not what you're using it to mean.
You're not familiar with the Babylonian Jewish exile stories in Judaism, I can tell. Let me know if you know this song:
By the rivers of babylon, there we sat down
Ye-eah we wept, when we remembered zion.
By the rivers of babylon, there we sat down
Ye-eah we wept, when we remembered zion.
When the wicked
Carried us away in captivity
Required from us a song
Now how shall we sing the lord's song in a strange land
When the wicked
Carried us away in captivity
Requiering of us a song
Now how shall we sing the lord's song in a strange land
Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah let the words of our mouth and the meditations of our heart
Be acceptable in thy sight here tonight
Let the words of our mouth and the meditation of our hearts
Be acceptable in thy sight here tonight
By the rivers of babylon, there we sat down
Ye-eah we wept, when we remembered zion.
By the rivers of babylon, there we sat down
Ye-eah we wept, when we remembered zion.
By the rivers of babylon (dark tears of babylon)
There we sat down (you got to sing a song)
Ye-eah we wept, (sing a song of love)
When we remember zion. (yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah)
By the rivers of babylon (rough bits of babylon)
There we sat down (you hear the people cry)
Ye-eah we wept, (they need their god)
When we remember zion. (ooh, have the power)
It's the Biblican psalm 137 set to music. After the Temple of Salomon fell, the Jews were exiled to Babylonia -- Khazaria as you call it.
Ashkenazi means "from Germany", by the way. You're saying that all of the jews from Germany came up with Zionism.
You're wrong. So incredibly wrong. You must know of Theodor Hertzl, the founder of modern day Zionism. He wasn't the leader of jews in Germany. You know all of this deep down, man.
To the people reading this: I had nothing better to do on Saturday night than to write this. Sorry.
Nope, Yiddish is a low-german dialect mixed with Hebrew words and the Hebrew aleph-bet. Moving along.
I'm not really, it's just -- oh, you mean that I literally can't? You're saying that like it's a fact and not an opinion?
Wrong, oh so very wrong. Read up on Judaism. I don't consider myself a "Jew" because my mother converted after college and then denounced it a couple of years after I was born, but technically I'm the son of a Jewish woman because she went through conversion. Religion, man. Trust me, I know this shit, you're just wrong on this one, man. Time to hang up the towel on this issue.
There are jews of all kinds of ethnicities and races because they intermingled with the local communities.
It happened in Germany, it happened in Ethiopia, it happened in America -- it doesn't mean that the Ethiopian Jews are any less Jewish than the Sephardim or Ashkenazi Jews.
what do I know, it's not like I grew up in it or anything. I speak Hebrew, but wha'da'I'know. I'm probably just being ruled over by the rothchilds, you're right.
It is the holy bible....the helios biblios: the book of the sunThat sounds like just the kind of thing an anti-semite might say lol
what do you mean?
can you give me an example?
It is the holy bible....the helios biblios: the book of the sun
I'm saying that a group of people have formed a political movement called 'zionism' and that they are then shouting 'anti-semite' at anyone who questions the actions of that political movement
They are doing that by using media that they control to equate zionism with judaism when the two are SEPERATE THINGS
First of all i'm not trivialising any sufferings that have gone on
Secondly that small number of people you refer to that you now seem to be admitting do indeed have massive influence over the financial sector and media and who are the driving force behind political zionism I am saying are not jews...if we are saying that a 'jew' is someone of the jewish faith then it is my belief that they are not jews
I believe that they are occultists hiding behind jews (they also hide behind christians and muslims sometimes as well)
Then you are defining being jewish as an ethnicity
This means that the zionist claim that the 'jews' have a historical right to the land of palestine is what the nazis would call a 'big lie': https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Big_lie
The young jews are getting confused as to why people in europe are criticising zionism because they have been lied to about what zionism is!!
But to give you a straight forward answer to what you are saying the answer is YES the jews are also told lies by the zionists and taught false history
I'm waiting for my brother to arrive for our weekly workout session, so I'll dig into this again.
Zionism is not just a political movement, it's a religious movement for Jewish people in exile (diaspora).
IAs for shouting anti-semite at people, there's a lot of anti-semitism around.
Look at Israel's defence of it's borders from countless attacks on it's right to exist,
if any other country was attacked the way they are constantly being attacked,
NATO would have set up missiles pointing in every which direction. Instead they're boycotting Israeli goods. What a world.
You are trivializing the sufferings that have gone on by saying that the Jews could just convert to any other religion and no longer be Jews.
IIf that was the case, you're saying that every Jew murdered in the 20th century could've avoided the suffering by simply denouncing their religion.
IYou're also assuming that every single Jewish person killed was an active practitioner of the Jewish religion, which is ridiculous.
10% of all Jewish people are keeping a secret about their true intentions, never once revealing their evil massive plan to drive the world into financial ruin. You're bonkers.
Being Jewish is an ethnicity.
It's one of the oldest around.
I've tried escaping that, but there is no denying that being born to a Jewish mother means that you're a Jew and always will be.
I'm not a practicing Jew (thank God) but technically I'm a MOT (Member Of the Tribe)
Being lied to about what zionism is?
Zion refers to Mount Zion, which was conquered by King David and named The City of David. It was then called Tzion (Zion) and that's where Salomon's Temple was built. The Temple was the gathering place for Jews during the era of Judea, and was destroyed twice and sent the Jewish people to exile (diaspora). That's what Zionism refers to, the longing for the City of David, Salomon's Temple, a gathering place for Jews to come home to.