Type Vote
- Thread starter cvp12gh5
- Start date
PintoBean
Site Supporter
- MBTI
- INFJ
- Enneagram
- 6
Interesting, I am on the fence about the E part.
- MBTI
- INTJ
I posted something thinking who the hell is abh. Then a little light went of in my head and I was like ooohhh.
Maybe intj but that doesn't feel right. You do not have this ..what I can only say seems like a robotic vibe. Most intjs I have come into contact with via type word give off more of a direct exacting focus. "Heres the topic, heres the thought on the topic, " with no real filler in between.
I dont claim to be able to guess the mbti of people well or all but I will say intp as an opinion.
Maybe intj but that doesn't feel right. You do not have this ..what I can only say seems like a robotic vibe. Most intjs I have come into contact with via type word give off more of a direct exacting focus. "Heres the topic, heres the thought on the topic, " with no real filler in between.
I dont claim to be able to guess the mbti of people well or all but I will say intp as an opinion.
hush
Retired Staff
- MBTI
- pocketoli
- Enneagram
- ☻
I considered E as well, BUT, really only as ENTJ. INFJ I could consider, but ENFJ just doesn't seem like a good fit.
How does dominant Fe feel to you, ABH?
I am also more confident about I because from what I've observed you have a decent balance of F and T - which would push more towards your decision making functions being secondary and tertiary, with perceiving (Ni) as dom.
As an ENTJ Te would be dominant, and Fi the fourth, weakest in your function stack. I can't really see that.
Whaddya think, darlin'?
drummergirlbk
Community Member
- MBTI
- INTJ
- Enneagram
- 5w4
I am affirming my stance on your INTJness. And it all comes down to this wonderful post from your blog:
Aside from how lucky your family is to have you, children also "change" you in ways you never imagined. How were you before the kids, I wonder. Anyway, kids can iron out all of those emotions and offer a clearer picture to the way that you reflect about and process your feelings. My hypothesis on this is simple, 1) as a mom, you don't have time to dwell in deep reflection for who knows how long to figure your feels out and 2) I think being a parent, a good parent, automatically makes you become more objective with communication but also from a more feely side. Your already high intuition also increases with parenting, aka "mommy's intuition", so I think you are naturally more aware of the feels in others. So, my final thoughts are that you are indeed an INTJ who knows her feels and are just more evolved. This is awesome, by the way.
I was going to say something very similar to this, but it looks like you beat me to it.
I had this same thing happen to me the other day.
Maybe has something to do with what [MENTION=13729]Free2be[/MENTION] mentioned?? I'm just speculating here. I'm not a mom, and people tell me that I have that vibe you mentioned. My brother's girlfriend actually told me that yesterday, go figure.
- MBTI
- INTJ
Ya might rabbit, ya might.
I was thinking about this a little more. INTJs have this monotone way of discussing things. So much so it even shows up in the way they type when in discussion mode. ABH gives off more of a good humor playful feeling. Muted..but still there nonetheless.
- MBTI
- INFJ
- Enneagram
- 295ish
You aren't easy to type because the truth is much of your preferences lie more in the in-between sector than on either side. This was true both on many of the Big 5 tests you posted and on the MBTI ones (and they're reasonably correlated, and are tapping into each other while retaining some clear uniqueness too).
I think Jungian function-attitudes-wise, you've got a reasonably egoic introverted feeling. However, just know that the type conversions INFJ => has Fe-Ti are highly dubious. People who test INFJ can have introverted>extraverted feeling easily. Some people more or less have quit analyzing the test, and just use INFJ as code for Fe-Ti, but I think that's overly restrictive, and even one MBTI scholar who helped write the MBTI types as an INTP with Se, not Si.
Just in case you feel stuck about this, Jung himself acknowledged there are many people in the middle, and modern psychometric testing research suggests strongly that personality dimensions of the Big 5 are closer to a normal curve, meaning there's no clear mark between where an "official T" and "official F" or "official E" and "official I" is... just relative positions.
You MIGHT have clearer preferences in the individual function-attitudes i.e. I think you seeeeem (based on reading your profile long ago, and some entries, when trying to type you) to be more introverted feeling than extraverted...maybe we can figure out the others too.
Know that dichotomies are catchy, because then you have one easily separated box out of 16, but the reality of type is more continuous/messy than that.
I think Jungian function-attitudes-wise, you've got a reasonably egoic introverted feeling. However, just know that the type conversions INFJ => has Fe-Ti are highly dubious. People who test INFJ can have introverted>extraverted feeling easily. Some people more or less have quit analyzing the test, and just use INFJ as code for Fe-Ti, but I think that's overly restrictive, and even one MBTI scholar who helped write the MBTI types as an INTP with Se, not Si.
Just in case you feel stuck about this, Jung himself acknowledged there are many people in the middle, and modern psychometric testing research suggests strongly that personality dimensions of the Big 5 are closer to a normal curve, meaning there's no clear mark between where an "official T" and "official F" or "official E" and "official I" is... just relative positions.
You MIGHT have clearer preferences in the individual function-attitudes i.e. I think you seeeeem (based on reading your profile long ago, and some entries, when trying to type you) to be more introverted feeling than extraverted...maybe we can figure out the others too.
Know that dichotomies are catchy, because then you have one easily separated box out of 16, but the reality of type is more continuous/messy than that.
cvp12gh5
What a lovely way to burn...
- MBTI
- Intui
- Enneagram
- Thinking
The first time I took it (years ago), my result was INFJ. I knew nothing about mbti and didn't look any further into it.
I then took it again a few years ago and received the same result. That time, I read more about it and ended up on the INFJ Forum. I took it several times after that and received different results. Frequent results: INFJ, INTJ, INTP. One timers: ISTJ, ISTP.
Which test do you find to be the best?
For me, the test on 16personalities.com appears to be the most accurate. Not just the test results, but every piece of information about my type that was provided, spoke to me in great depth.
If you want some of the common function-attitude based tests out there, check out http://www.sociotype.com/tests/ and http://www.keys2cognition.com/explore.htm
But know that it's better to use these just to get more data than it is to actually go by their predicted results unless they really resonate. The first is a socionics test. I recommend going with the "original" not "extended" option because the latter uses visual identification which I don't think much of, the original part uses just the ideas. Far from perfect, but still, for some tools to play with.
But know that it's better to use these just to get more data than it is to actually go by their predicted results unless they really resonate. The first is a socionics test. I recommend going with the "original" not "extended" option because the latter uses visual identification which I don't think much of, the original part uses just the ideas. Far from perfect, but still, for some tools to play with.
Misadventure
butt fros and asian purrs
- MBTI
- INFP
- Enneagram
- 4
I also typed as an infj. After I had my kids, I often type intj, intp, and more often than others infp. So, I stick to that, lol. What free2be said makes a lot of sense to me, I felt that my kids changed me too, in how I think and process information to how I deal with everyday stuff. They even bring out many extroverted qualities in me that I never knew I had. My husband is an INTJ, a softie one at that, and I know it's because of our kids. There are many studies out there that say parents with small children are the most mis-typed out there because the effect them on your personality.
I also agree with JJJA that the 16 personalities has been the better one that I go to, but similar minds also has a good one. The problem I face with these tests, than many intj and infjs deal with, is that so many of the questions could go either way. In the end it just made me more confused dwelling on it so I just choose not to dwell anymore.
I also agree with JJJA that the 16 personalities has been the better one that I go to, but similar minds also has a good one. The problem I face with these tests, than many intj and infjs deal with, is that so many of the questions could go either way. In the end it just made me more confused dwelling on it so I just choose not to dwell anymore.
cvp12gh5
What a lovely way to burn...
- MBTI
- Intui
- Enneagram
- Thinking
Sociotype.com results:
Test Result
Your Sociotype: ILI-1Ni NiTe (INTp)
Intuitive Logical Introvert - The Critic
Brief Description of the ILI
Using introverted intuition as his base function and extroverted thinking as his creative, the ILI is capable of deep and vivid imagery as well as the ability to analyze the correctness of conclusions. In fact, the ILI is excellent at critiquing everything from someone's statements and conclusions to the food he eats. They have an inherent understanding of the weak points in any argument, and they are particularly adept at identifying both empirical weaknesses and logical inconsistencies. As paradoxical as it might sound, the ILI has both the ability to foresee future trends and events, while at the same time refusing to make any assumptions that lack a thorough empirical backing. At his best, the ILI will act as a very useful advisor, pointing out weaknesses and flaws that he sees, while also making suggestions for improvements. At his worst, the ILI's penchant for deep and secluded thoughts, coupled with his refusal to sacrifice truth and accuracy in favor of diplomacy, can result in leaving him socially isolated.
LII (INTj): 96% as likely as ILI. Compare the ILI (INTp) and LII (INTj)
EII (INFj): 87% as likely as ILI. Compare the ILI (INTp) and EII (INFj)
LIE (ENTj): 80% as likely as ILI. Compare the ILI (INTp) and LIE (ENTj)
drummergirlbk
Community Member
- MBTI
- INTJ
- Enneagram
- 5w4
If I'm not mistaken, socionics INTp is often said to be the equivilent of MBTI's INTJ. I also agree with what [MENTION=13855]JJJA[/MENTION] and [MENTION=13723]Misadventure[/MENTION] said about http://16personalities.com.
- MBTI
- INFJ
- Enneagram
- 295ish
Indeed, Socionics INTp = MBTI INTJ. I also agree with the http://16personalities.com. I like socionics as well, as it does offer some more in depth explanation to the functions.
ENTJ = ENTj/LIE
ENTP = ENTp/ILE
ENFJ = ENFj/EIE
ENFP = ENFp/IEE
ESFJ = ESFj/ESE
ESFP = ESFp/SEE
ESTJ = ESTj/LSE
ESTP = ESTp/SLE
INTJ = INTp/ILI (NiTE)
INTP = INTj/LII (TiNE)
INFJ = INFp/IEI (NiFE)
INFP = INFj/EII (FiNE)
ISFJ = ISFp/SEI (SiFE)
ISFP = ISFj/ESI (FiSE)
ISTJ = ISTp/SLI (SiTE)
ISTP = ISTj/LSI (TiSE)
https://forum.socionix.com/topic/2111-mbti-socionics-type-correspondence-chart/
[MENTION=12327]Anywhere But Here[/MENTION]
Since you're new to socionics, here's my interpretation (tentatively) of your test results: you got as top two picks the two introverted NTs, and the other two were both socionics Fi+Te types (and ILI is also one).
So overall what it seems to be telling you is you scored high mainly on NT stuff, slant introverted, and value Fi (in their system) (EII, the third choice, leads with Fi).
I think that's overall my impression of you too... something tells me you're one of those NTs with strong F to back it up. But this is just a holistic assessment.
Since you're new to socionics, here's my interpretation (tentatively) of your test results: you got as top two picks the two introverted NTs, and the other two were both socionics Fi+Te types (and ILI is also one).
So overall what it seems to be telling you is you scored high mainly on NT stuff, slant introverted, and value Fi (in their system) (EII, the third choice, leads with Fi).
I think that's overall my impression of you too... something tells me you're one of those NTs with strong F to back it up. But this is just a holistic assessment.
cvp12gh5
What a lovely way to burn...
- MBTI
- Intui
- Enneagram
- Thinking
[MENTION=1669]Gist[/MENTION] [MENTION=13729]Free2be[/MENTION]
I'm strapped for time, but when I get a minute or 10, I'll make a post with my personality traits that have stood out over the years. And then maybe you can help me determine from there.
[MENTION=1669]Gist[/MENTION]
[MENTION=13729]Free2be[/MENTION]
I'm having difficulty in determining where to start. I want to provide relevant information without oversharing. Would you like to ask specific questions? You don't have to, but it would help.